input[type="number"] is valid when not a number is entered in Chrome

When entering invalid data into second field in Chrome - second is marked as pristine and valid which is incorrect.
Possible Chrome bug - parser from numberInputType is not invoked when typing non-numerics in Chrome

<input type="text" ng-model="test">
<input type="number" ng-model="test">
{{test}}

live example: http://plnkr.co/edit/fULfvq?p=preview

Somebody raised this issue on the list recently.
https://groups.google.com/d/topic/angular/pRc5pu3bWQ0/discussion

From http://www.w3.org/TR/html5/forms.html#number-state-(type=number)

User agents must not allow the user to set the value to a non-empty string that is not a valid floating-point number.

and

If the value of the element is not a valid floating-point number, then set it to the empty string instead.

If this problem only occurs when the browser is doing validation and the validation it's doing is the validation we want, it makes sense for the input directive to just observe the validity state of the DOM element.

I ran into this today as well. Actually, Firefox, Chrome and IE10 each handle this scenario (entering a non-number into a number input) differently which makes it a mess.

Firefox seems to handle it the way I would expect (or at least the way I want it to be handled).
Chrome, as noted, treats it as valid all the time.
And IE10 treats it as valid if there are no numbers in the input but NOT valid if there are some numbers and some letters.

Here is a plunker I put together based off the plunker in the Angular docs:
http://plnkr.co/SLnME6zXm653dLPHmjSr

This was definitely not expected. I too was wondering why "asdf" was treated as a valid numeric input in Chrome.

Just ran into this today myself. If this isn't a bug, at least a note in the documentation would be nice.

I ran into this as well, and noticed that the validation works when the required attribute is added to the input field, e.g:

<input type="number" ng-model="myNumber" required />

To me it feels like an Angular bug, because it doesn't add the ng-invalid class to the field without the required attribute.

Edit I've now tried with Firefox and there it works without the required attribute, so maybe it's an Chrome bug after all...

@joakimbeng

@joakimbeng see the comment from @jglinsek - Firefox handles the validation as expected. I think the difference is that Chrome doesn't expose the value at all when the field is filled out with something other than a number, but Firefox does.

@groner

Also ran into this issue today. Firefox works as I expect. Chrome... not so much.

Issue is that when a non-number is entered into a number field in Chrome, it always returns an empty string from input.value

As @groner has pointed out, that is what the spec says to do. Although technically Chrome also shouldn't allow the input field to contain non-valid data. Pressing 'B' shouldn't produce a 'B' in the input field which would avoid this whole issue.

So because non-valid input always returns empty string, the listener function in textInputType is constantly comparing empty string to empty string, and thus never calling $apply which triggers the parsing etc. This is why the number error is never being raised, since it's an empty string, which is perfectly valid.

I'm happy to contribute a patch to try to solve this, but would love to get some general direction from core Angular developers as to the general strategy I should use to tackle this.

Hey guys!

Any news on this one?

I'm currently using Kai's solution posted here:
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/angular/pRc5pu3bWQ0/discussion

Is this really the solution to this issue?

As far as I know things haven't progressed at all with this. Still an issue with Chrome. Kai's works. You could also create a simple number type directive yourself that follows the spec and use that.

They said in that google groups discussion that validity.badInput is set to true, and it is -- The problem is that this is hard to test for. It doesn't seem to happen when the value is set programmatically and the change or input event is fired.

If the value is required, then we can depend on value.length === 0 && validity.valueMissing === false --- But unfortunately, this doesn't really help for values which are not "required".

Ultimately I sort of feel like this is a browser bug. I think checking for validity.badInput is enough to accommodate browsers which provide ValidityState for HTMLInputELements, but I don't think there's any nice way to test this without selenium or something.

I've opened an issue at #304455 about it. Maybe I'm wrong, but it would be good to get people considering whether sanitizing an invalid string by simply returning an empty string is the "right thing to do". I certainly don't see any mention of doing this in the specs anywhere, unless I'm missing something.

As a note: Desktop FF (at least, FF26.0a1 (2013-09-06)) does not seem to support input[type=number] at all, which may explain why you're seeing this behaviour. Opera 12.15 behaves identically to Chrome (did they already switch to Blink for that release?). IE8 does not discard value, and it still claims that type=number, but it doesn't appear to treat it any differently from text, and there is no ValidityState that I can see.

So, I'm not sure how this is on newer versions of IE, but for other browsers it seems like we're either treated as text or we have our value discarded, which breaks the validation code.

So I think the reason why this might work well for FF is because it's actually input[type=text], heh.

But still, I don't see anything in the spec that says this should be the way it works, and I don't really feel like it's very helpful.

Gave it another shot, and this sort of works. demo

Definitely needs some review to improve things.

fix(input): use ValidityState to determine validity

hawtio#1123 Added validation on the number field in Fabric-CreateNewC…

Is it correct to say that when an invalid number is entered in Chrome on an input of type number that it will always be marked invalid and Angular can only get a blank string? Thus there is no way to support entering commas on a numeric input.

Pretty much :)

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

input[type="number"] is valid when not a number is entered in Chrome #2144

11 remaining items

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

input[type="number"] is valid when not a number is entered in Chrome #2144

Description

Activity

groner commented on Mar 12, 2013

jglinsek commented on Apr 18, 2013

thatmarvin commented on Apr 19, 2013

kevin1024 commented on Apr 24, 2013

joakimbeng commented on Apr 24, 2013

kevin1024 commented on Apr 25, 2013

owenmead commented on Apr 30, 2013

michaelhunziker commented on Jul 3, 2013

owenmead commented on Jul 4, 2013

caitp commented on Oct 5, 2013

caitp commented on Oct 6, 2013

11 remaining items

axelson commented on May 20, 2015

gkalpak commented on May 20, 2015

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions